Brown, J., J. 1001496 Kim Butler v. Town of Argo (Appeal from Jefferson Circuit ( 13 ) Court: CV-98-4869). Dismissed. 1002162 Paul Jennings v. Kim Butler (Appeal from Jefferson Circuit ( 13 ) Court: CV-98-4869). Reversed. 1002163 Kathryn Ayres v. Kim Butler (Appeal from Jefferson Circuit ( 13 ) Court: CV-98-4869). Reversed. 1002164 John Wayne Fore v. Kim Butler (Appeal from Jefferson Circuit ( 13 ) Court: CV-98-4869). Reversed. 1010017 Kim Butler v. Paul Jennings et al. (Appeal from Jefferson ( 13 ) Circuit Court: CV-98-4869). Dismissed As Moot. PER CURIAM 1000143 Paul L. Spain, as administrator for the estate of Carolyn Watts Spain, deceased v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporation et al. (Certified Question from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit: 11th Cir.Ct.No.:99-15921; D.C.No. 99-02424-CV-AR-S)). CERTIFIED QUESTION I AND CERTIFIED QUESTIONS a. and b. ANSWERED; OTHER REMAINING QUESTIONS DECLINED. 1001644 Brenda D. Tillman, as executrix under the last will and testament of Kalen Oliver Tillman, deceased v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company et al. (Certified Question from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit: 11th Cir.No. 00-10963; D.C.No.; 98-00748-CV-BH-M)). Question Answered. 1000143 Appellant M. Clay Ragsdale, IV, Birmingham Appellee W. Randall Bassett, Atlanta GA Appellee William H. Brooks, Birmingham Appellee Mark C. Cawley, Washington DC Appellee David S. Eggert, Washington DC Appellee Samuel H. Franklin, Birmingham Appellee Steven N. Geise, Cleveland OH Appellee Peter M. Henk, Houston TX Appellee Daniel A. Hillman, Atlanta GA Appellee Paul D. Koethe, Cleveland OH Appellee Heather A. Pigman, Washington DC Appellee Randall D. Quarles, Birmingham Appellee Stephen J. Rowe, Birmingham Appellee Stephen Scheve, Houston TX Appellee Steven R. Selsberg, Houston TX Appellee Gordon A. Smith, Atlanta GA Appellee Richard G. Stuhan, Cleveland OH Appellee William B. Wahlheim, Jr., Birmingham Appellee H. Thomas Wells, Jr., Birmingham Appellee Vernon L. Wells, II, Birmingham Amicus Aplt. Jere L. Beasley, Montgomery Amicus Aplt. Ross Diamond, III, Mobile Amicus Aplt. Robert Graham Esdale, Jr., Montgomery Amicus Pet. David G. Wirtes, Jr., Mobile Amicus Aple. Allison L. Alford, Montgomery Amicus Aple. Joana S. Ellis, Montgomery Amicus Aple. Emily C. Marks, Montgomery 1001496 Appellant Tom Burgess, Birmingham Appellee Robert Baugh, Birmingham Appellee Hugh E. Holladay, Pell City Appellee Kerry P. McInerney, Birmingham Appellee James R. Shaw, Birmingham Appellee R. Gordon Sproule, Birmingham 1001644 Appellant Jere L. Beasley, Montgomery Appellant Ross Diamond, III, Mobile Appellant Robert Graham Esdale, Jr., Montgomery Appellee Joseph P. H. Babington, Mobile Appellee William H. Brooks, Birmingham Appellee John T. Dukes, Mobile Appellee Samuel H. Franklin, Birmingham Appellee Frederick G. Helmsing, Mobile Appellee Stephen J. Rowe, Birmingham Appellee Thomas D. Schroeder, Winston Salem NC 1002162 Appellant Robert Baugh, Birmingham Appellant Kerry P. McInerney, Birmingham Appellee Tom Burgess, Birmingham 1002163 Appellant James R. Shaw, Birmingham Appellee Tom Burgess, Birmingham 1002164 Appellant James R. Shaw, Birmingham Appellee Tom Burgess, Birmingham 1010017 Appellant Tom Burgess, Birmingham Appellee Robert Baugh, Birmingham Appellee James R. Shaw, Birmingham